5 Best Breville Toasters to Buy in 2026

For those seeking the ultimate Breville toasting experience in a compact footprint, the Breville Toast Select Luxe is a truly premium choice. This model doesn’t just toast; it intelligently adjusts time for six different bread types—Whole Wheat, White, Bagel, Waffles, Pastries, and English Muffin—taking the guesswork out of breakfast. The intuitive LED indicator provides a clear countdown, letting you know exactly how much longer until perfection, a small but significant feature for busy mornings. It’s designed to solve the common pain point of uneven or improperly timed toasting for varied items.

Performance is exceptionally consistent across its varied settings, handling everything from delicate pastries to thick, dense bagels thanks to its wide slots and 1000 Watts of power. The manual ‘Lift & Look’ feature is a classic control, allowing you to check progress mid-cycle without interruption, while ‘A Bit More’ saves under-toasted items effortlessly. While limited to two slices, its ability to perfectly crisp diverse bread types makes it highly versatile for singles or couples. It maintains a relatively small counter presence compared to larger models.

Positioned as the “Best Overall” Breville toaster in a 2-slice format, the Breville BTA735SHY offers a richer feature set, particularly the diverse preset bread types, compared to the more basic Breville Bit More BTA70XL. Unlike the Breville Smart Toaster BTA00140SC64 with its auto-lowering, this Luxe model retains a manual lever, appealing to those who prefer tactile control. It offers superior bread-specific performance and detailed feedback than the budget-friendly Breville BTA70XL.

Families or those who frequently toast larger or multiple bread items will find the Breville Die-Cast Long Slot Smart Toaster BTA830XL an absolute game-changer. Boasting an extra-long 4-slice capacity, it effortlessly accommodates artisanal loaves, multiple standard slices, or full-sized bagels side-by-side, eliminating the need for multiple batches. The one-touch auto lowering and lifting mechanism is incredibly smooth and convenient, adding a touch of modern luxury to your kitchen routine. This unit is built to handle the demands of a busy household wanting consistent results fast.

With a powerful 1600 Watts, this Breville toaster delivers quick and even toasting across its four extra-long slots. Features like ‘Lift & Look’ and ‘A Bit More’ work seamlessly with the auto-lift mechanism, offering convenience and control. The dedicated Bagel and Defrost functions ensure perfectly customized results for these common items. Its robust, die-cast construction feels exceptionally durable, though its generous capacity means it occupies a larger footprint on the countertop.

Compared to the 2-slice Breville models like the Breville Luxe BTA735SHY or the Breville Smart BTA00140SC64, the Breville BTA830XL’s primary advantage is its capacity and long slots, making it ideal for larger families or unique bread types. While it offers fewer preset bread types than the Luxe BTA735SHY, its automation and size make it a superior choice for volume and versatility with larger items. It represents a significant step up in capacity and features from the budget Breville Bit More BTA70XL.

If lightning-fast toast is your top priority, the Café Express Finish 2-Slice Toaster is engineered specifically for speed. Its standout Express Finish mode promises beautifully browned toast in about a minute, a significant time saver during rushed mornings. Coupled with extra-wide 1.38-inch slots, this toaster is also highly capable of handling thicker items like bagels, waffles, or Texas toast without jamming. An attractive LED ring provides a clear visual cue of the toasting progress, blinking when ready.

Beyond its speed, the Café toaster offers practical functionality with four preset modes including Bagel, Reheat, and Frozen, alongside the signature Express Finish. The eight selectable shade options provide a wide range of browning control, catering to individual preferences. While it excels in quick performance and versatility for thick items, its core function is speed, which might mean slightly less nuanced control compared to models with variable browning dials that aren’t tied to specific time presets.

Positioned against Breville toasters, the Café B0964CN2XN differentiates itself primarily on its Express Finish speed, a feature not found on the Breville models in this comparison. While Breville offers ‘A Bit More’ for fine-tuning, the Café focuses on getting standard toast done quickly. Compared to the budget Breville Bit More BTA70XL, the Café offers more preset functions and shade options, emphasizing speed and versatility for thick items over Breville’s core ‘Bit More’ philosophy. It offers a different value proposition centered on rapid results.

The Breville Die-Cast Smart Toaster BTA00140SC64 brings automation and smart features to a standard 2-slice format, making it a compelling choice for those who appreciate convenience. Its one-touch auto lowering and lifting mechanism provides a smooth, controlled descent and ascent for your bread, a small luxury that feels distinctly premium. The integrated ‘Lift & Look’ and ‘A Bit More’ functions work effortlessly with the automatic control, allowing for progress checks or extra toasting time at the touch of a button. This model addresses the desire for precision and ease of use in a compact size.

Performance is solid and reliable, with 900 Watts of power and wide slots capable of handling thicker items like bagels and pastries. The variable browning control paired with the LED indicator allows for precise shade selection and monitoring. Dedicated Bagel and Defrost functions add further versatility, ensuring optimal results for frozen items or unevenly shaped bagels. While its 2-slice capacity is standard, the automation sets it apart from manually operated units.

As the “Best Mid Range” Breville 2-slice option, the Breville BTA00140SC64 stands out from the budget Breville Bit More BTA70XL by offering automatic operation and a more integrated smart experience, including the LED progress indicator. Compared to the Breville Luxe BTA735SHY, it trades the Luxe’s diverse bread presets for the convenience of auto-lowering. It provides a balance of smart features and compact size, sitting below the high-capacity BTA830XL but above the entry-level Breville BTA70XL in terms of automation and control features.

For those seeking core Breville functionality without the premium price tag, the Breville Bit More Toaster BTA70XL is an excellent budget-friendly option. Its namesake ‘A Bit More’ button is a standout feature, allowing you to easily add a short burst of extra toasting time with a single press, perfectly rescuing toast that’s just shy of ideal. Coupled with the manual ‘Lift & Look’ lever, you have simple, effective tools to ensure your toast is just right every time, addressing the common frustration of under-toasted bread.

This compact 2-slice toaster offers 1000 Watts of power and wide slots, making it capable of handling standard bread, bagels, and thicker items adequately. It includes basic functions like Bagel and Defrost, covering essential toasting needs. The LED indicator provides a visual reference for the toasting cycle’s progress. While it lacks the automation or extensive presets of higher-end models, its straightforward operation and focus on the core ‘A Bit More’ and ‘Lift & Look’ features make it highly practical for everyday use.

Positioned as the most accessible Breville toaster in this lineup, the Breville BTA70XL strips away some of the bells and whistles found on models like the Breville Luxe BTA735SHY or the Breville Smart BTA00140SC64. It relies on a manual lever rather than automation and offers fewer specific bread presets than the Luxe. However, it retains the essential Breville ‘A Bit More’ and ‘Lift & Look’ features at a significantly lower cost, providing solid performance for the value compared to other basic toasters on the market.