6 Best Toasters for Crumpets of 2026

For those seeking a straightforward, no-fuss toaster that gets the job done without breaking the bank, the BLACK+DECKER 2-Slice is a compelling option. Its intuitive 7-shade selector allows for simple customization, ensuring your toast is exactly how you like it, from lightly warmed to deeply browned. The inclusion of auto-centering guides is a thoughtful touch, promoting more even results than basic manual placement. This unit focuses on essential functionality, providing reliable performance for everyday toasting needs.

Performance is predictable for standard bread slices, consistently delivering results based on the selected shade. It handles basic toasting tasks efficiently, and the removable crumb tray makes cleanup incredibly easy. While its slots are suitable for standard bread, thicker items like larger crumpets or chunky bagels might require more effort or not fit comfortably. The auto shut-off and cancel functions add safety and convenience, making it a reliable appliance for quick morning routines.

Compared to the GE 2 Slice, the BLACK+DECKER offers a more minimalist feature set and a lower entry point. It lacks the illuminated buttons and extra-wide slot dimensions of the GE, focusing purely on core toasting. This makes it ideal for users who prioritize simplicity and budget over versatility or specific features for thicker items. Its value proposition lies in offering dependable basic toasting performance at a highly accessible cost.

The Mueller UltraToast stands out as a feature-rich, high-capacity toaster designed for busy households and diverse toasting preferences. Its four long, extra-wide 1.6-inch slots are a major highlight, easily accommodating not just standard bread but also generous crumpets, thick bagels, and artisan loaves. The LED display and touch controls add a modern touch, providing clear feedback and easy adjustment of the six browning levels. This unit tackles the challenge of toasting various bread types simultaneously with considerable success.

In real-world use, the Mueller UltraToast performs admirably across different items. The self-centering guides work effectively to ensure even browning, even with irregular shapes like crumpets. The Defrost and Reheat functions add significant utility, allowing you to toast items straight from the freezer or warm up previously toasted goods without overcooking. While the six shade settings cover the basic range, some users might miss the finer control offered by models with seven or more levels, though the memory recall is a convenient compensation.

Positioned as a versatile mid-range option, the Mueller UltraToast offers significantly more capacity and features than the 2-slice GE model, particularly with its long slots and multiple functions. It provides excellent value for families or those who regularly toast varied items, including multiple crumpets at once. While it doesn’t boast the premium build or specialized one-sided toasting of the high-end Dualit, its combination of capacity, wide slots, and functional modes makes it a strong contender for everyday versatility at a more accessible price point.

GE’s 2 Slice Stainless Steel Toaster is crafted for users who need flexibility in bread types without sacrificing countertop space. Featuring extra-wide 1.38-inch slots, it comfortably handles thicker items like bagels, waffles, and even generous crumpets, a significant advantage over standard 2-slice toasters. The 7-shade setting dial provides precise control over browning, allowing you to dial in the exact level of doneness you prefer, from a light golden crisp to a deep, satisfying brown. This toaster is built for everyday versatility in a compact form factor.

Performance testing shows the GE 2 Slice delivers consistent, even toasting across both slots, thanks to its efficient heating element. The wide slots make inserting and retrieving bulkier items much easier, which is particularly helpful for delicate crumpets. While it excels at handling different bread sizes, it lacks the specialized functions like reheat or defrost found on other models, focusing purely on the core toasting process. The removable crumb tray simplifies cleaning, maintaining hygiene effortlessly.

Compared to the basic BLACK+DECKER 2-slice, the GE offers superior slot width and a more robust feel, justifying its slightly higher price point for users who frequently toast thicker items. It competes closely with the VQ Laura Ashley in terms of features like 7 shade settings and wide slots, but the VQ adds a high-lift lever and warming rack, potentially making it slightly better suited specifically for small crumpets, though the GE is arguably more straightforward. The GE hits a sweet spot for those needing a reliable, versatile 2-slice toaster capable of handling a wider variety of baked goods.

The VQ Laura Ashley Elveden toaster is specifically designed with versatility and convenience in mind, making it an excellent candidate for toasting a variety of items, including luscious crumpets. Its extra-wide, auto-centering slots ensure that even thick slices or irregularly shaped items are positioned correctly for even heating. The 7 heat settings offer precise control over browning, catering to individual preferences for everything from lightly warmed pastries to deeply toasted bread. This unit blends elegant design with practical features for a superior toasting experience.

A standout feature for crumpet enthusiasts is the high-lift lever, which allows you to safely retrieve smaller items without burning your fingers – a common pain point with standard toasters. The included warming rack is a unique addition, perfect for gently heating croissants or keeping your toast warm while you prepare other breakfast components. Performance is consistent, with Defrost and Reheat modes adding flexibility for frozen goods or warming up cooled toast. The anti-jam function provides an extra layer of safety and reliability during use.

When compared to the GE 2 Slice, the VQ Laura Ashley offers a similar feature set with wide slots and 7 shades, but distinguishes itself with the high-lift lever and warming rack, making it arguably better equipped for handling crumpets and other small items. While it’s priced higher than standard budget or mid-range 2-slice models like the BLACK+DECKER, its specific features catering to items like crumpets and bagels, combined with its stylish design and quality build, justify its position for users prioritizing these capabilities and aesthetics.

The bella 2 Slice Slim Toaster offers a clever, space-saving design without compromising on toasting functionality. Its most distinctive feature is the single, extra-long 10-inch slot, which can accommodate two standard slices side-by-side or a single, long piece of artisan bread, baguette, or even multiple crumpets lined up. The slim 3.58-inch profile is a major advantage for kitchens with limited counter space, proving that you don’t need a bulky appliance for versatile toasting. It’s a smart solution for modern, compact living.

Performance is reliable for its size and design. The auto-centering guides within the long slot help ensure even coverage, regardless of what you’re toasting. The high-lift lever is particularly useful for retrieving smaller items like English muffins or crumpets from the deep slot without hassle. With 6 shade settings and Reheat/Cancel functions, it covers the essential bases for everyday use. While six shades might offer slightly less precision than models with seven, it’s sufficient for most preferences.

Compared to a standard 2-slice toaster like the BLACK+DECKER, the bella Slim offers significantly more flexibility in terms of bread size and type due to its unique long slot. It provides a different form factor than the wider Mueller 4-slice, focusing on length over width and capacity. This makes the bella ideal for users who need to toast varied bread shapes (including crumpets) but are severely constrained by countertop depth, offering a great balance of versatility and minimal footprint.

The Dualit Classic 2 Slice NewGen is a premium, iconic toaster renowned for its durability, repairability, and unique toasting method. Unlike most toasters, it features ProHeat® elements designed to last longer and provide superior heat distribution, and crucially, these elements are replaceable, ensuring the toaster can serve you for years. Each unit is hand-built in the UK, reflecting a commitment to quality craftsmanship that sets it apart from mass-produced appliances. This is a toaster built to be an heirloom.

Performance is controlled via a mechanical timer, offering a different user experience than digital controls, requiring a bit of learning curve for precise timing. The slot selector is a practical feature, allowing you to heat just one slot when toasting a single slice, saving energy. It includes a special setting for bagels and crumpets that toasts the cut side while warming the other, a specific technique favored by some. While it lacks a high-lift mechanism, the build quality and unique features are its primary focus.

Positioned at the very top of the price spectrum in this comparison, the Dualit Classic offers a fundamentally different value proposition than models like the VQ Laura Ashley or GE. It prioritizes longevity, repairability, and a distinct toasting style (especially for crumpets/bagels) over modern digital conveniences or high-lift levers. It is the ideal choice for buyers who value exceptional build quality, sustainability through repair, and a classic aesthetic, willing to invest significantly more for a toaster designed to last a lifetime rather than just a few years.