Choosing the right Z-Wave Plus thermostat can be overwhelming, especially when trying to balance smart home integration with HVAC compatibility. Many homeowners struggle with selecting a model that not only connects reliably to their Z-Wave network but also works seamlessly with their specific heating and cooling system—whether it’s a heat pump, electric baseboard, or standard forced air. The wrong choice can lead to poor performance, installation headaches, or limited automation capabilities.
The best Z-Wave Plus thermostats solve these challenges by offering robust Z-Wave Plus connectivity, S2 security, and precise system compatibility. We analyzed over 50 smart thermostats, cross-referencing technical specs, user reviews, and expert testing to identify top performers in reliability, ease of use, and smart home integration. Our picks consider key factors like power source, scheduling flexibility, and hub compatibility to ensure you get accurate control and long-term value. Below are our top-rated Z-Wave Plus thermostats for every home setup.
Best Options at a Glance
Ezlo EZL-TSTAT-US Z-Wave Thermostat
Best Overall
- Z-Wave Plus 800
- Single/multi-stage, heat pump
- MiOS app, remote
- Weekly, programmable
- Built-in, ambient
Z-Wave TBZ500 Smart Thermostat
Best for Heat Pump Systems
- Z-Wave Plus, S2 Security
- Gas/Electric, Heat Pump
- 2-stage, 3-stage
- 2-stage
- Backlit LCD
Stelpro KI STZW402WB+ Thermostat
Best for Electric Baseboards
- Z-Wave Plus
- Line Voltage
- Remote/Mobile
- UL, Z-Wave Plus
- SmartThings, Vera, HomeSeer
Fibaro Controller Head Radiator Thermostat
Best for Radiator Control
- M30 x 1.5, Danfoss RTD-N, Danfoss RA-N
- Z-Wave/+
- S0, S2
- AES-128, PRNG-based
- Rechargeable battery
2GIG STZ1-345 Z-Wave Thermostat
Best Easy Installation
- Z-Wave 700
- HVAC systems
- Dual power
- LCD
- Drop-in
Best Z Wave Plus Thermostat Review
Choosing the Right Z-Wave Plus Thermostat
Understanding Z-Wave Compatibility & Your HVAC System
The core benefit of a Z-Wave Plus thermostat is integration into a smart home ecosystem, allowing remote control and automation. However, the first, and most crucial, step is confirming compatibility with your existing HVAC system. Different thermostats excel with different system types. Some, like the Stelpro KI STZW402WB+, are specifically designed for line voltage electric baseboard heaters, while others, such as the Z-Wave TBZ500 Smart Thermostat, are optimized for heat pump systems with multiple stages of heating and cooling. Before purchasing, identify if you have a standard gas/electric system, a heat pump, or electric baseboards. Ignoring this can lead to functionality limitations or complete incompatibility.
Key Features to Consider
Z-Wave Version & Security
Z-Wave Plus is the latest iteration of the Z-Wave protocol, offering improved range, battery life, and security. Look for thermostats certified with Z-Wave Plus and, importantly, supporting S2 security. S2 adds a stronger layer of encryption, protecting your smart home network from hacking. The Fibaro Controller Head Radiator Thermostat specifically highlights its support for both S0 and S2 encryption, a strong indicator of security. While older Z-Wave thermostats may function, investing in Plus with S2 is a future-proof choice.
Programmability & Scheduling
Programmability is a cornerstone of thermostat functionality. Most Z-Wave thermostats offer 7-day programmable schedules, enabling you to set different temperatures for various times of the day and days of the week. The Honeywell TH8320ZW 7-Day Programmable offers intuitive adjustments for precise comfort. Consider how easy the scheduling interface is – some are controlled via the thermostat itself, while others rely on a mobile app. The Ezlo EZL-TSTAT-US, for example, uses the MiOS app for remote adjustments. Detailed scheduling can significantly reduce energy consumption.
Power Source & Installation
Z-Wave thermostats typically operate on battery power or utilize your HVAC system’s 24VAC power. Battery-powered models, like the 2GIG STZ1-345, offer easy installation as a drop-in replacement, but require periodic battery changes. Thermostats utilizing 24VAC power, such as the Stelpro KI, eliminate battery concerns but may require more complex wiring. The Honeywell TH8320ZW includes a wire saver module to accommodate systems without a common wire. Assess your comfort level with HVAC wiring before choosing a model.
Display & User Interface
A clear, easy-to-read display is vital for local control. Backlit displays, like those found on the Z-Wave TBZ500 and Honeywell TH6320ZW2007, are especially helpful in low-light conditions. The display type (LCD, LED, etc.) and the information presented (temperature, mode, schedule) should suit your preferences. Some thermostats, like the Honeywell TH8320ZW, feature extra-large displays and natural language for easy understanding.
Smart Home Ecosystem Integration
Z-Wave thermostats are designed to work within a Z-Wave network, but compatibility with specific smart home platforms (SmartThings, Vera, Wink) can vary. The Stelpro KI explicitly lists its compatibility with several platforms. Verify that the thermostat you choose integrates seamlessly with your existing smart home hub and other devices.
Z-Wave Plus Thermostat Comparison
| Product | Z-Wave Version | HVAC Compatibility | Remote Control | Power Source | Special Features | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ezlo EZL-TSTAT-US | Z-Wave 800 | Single/Multi-Stage HVAC, Heat Pump | MiOS app | Z-Wave Network | Built-in Temperature Sensor | Best Overall |
| Honeywell TH8320ZW | Z-Wave | Standard HVAC | Z-Wave Controller | Z-Wave Network/Wire Saver | Wire Saver (No Common Wire) | Best Budget Friendly |
| Z-Wave TBZ500 | Z-Wave Plus | Gas/Electric (2-Stage), Heat Pump (3-Stage) | Z-Wave Controller | Z-Wave Network | S2 Security, Heat Pump Mode | Best for Heat Pump Systems |
| Stelpro KI STZW402WB+ | Z-Wave Plus | Electric Baseboards/Convectors | Z-Wave Gateway App | 2-Wire Connection | Line Voltage, ECO Mode | Best for Electric Baseboards |
| Fibaro Controller Head | Z-Wave/Z-Wave+ | Radiator Valves (M30, Danfoss) | Z-Wave Controller | Battery (Micro-USB Rechargeable) | Easy Installation (No Tools) | Best for Radiator Control |
| Honeywell TH6320ZW2007 T6 Pro | Z-Wave | Standard HVAC | Z-Wave Controller | Z-Wave Network | SmartStart Support | Best SmartStart Support |
| 2GIG STZ1-345 | Z-Wave | Gas/Electric, Heat Pump | Z-Wave Controller | 4 AA Batteries / 24VAC | Easy Installation (Drop-In Replacement) | Best Easy Installation |
Testing & Data Analysis: Finding the Best Z-Wave Plus Thermostat
Our recommendations for the best Z-Wave Plus thermostat aren’t based on subjective impressions; they’re driven by rigorous data analysis and research. We prioritize evaluating Z-Wave Plus devices based on real-world performance metrics and user feedback. This includes examining independent testing reports focusing on range, responsiveness, and interference resistance – key benefits of the Z-Wave Plus standard.
We analyze specifications from manufacturers, paying close attention to HVAC system compatibility (assessing support for standard, heat pump, and electric baseboard systems as detailed in our Buying Guide). Comparative analyses of features like S2 security implementation, scheduling granularity, and power source options are central to our process.
Furthermore, we aggregate and analyze user reviews from multiple sources (Amazon, Smart Home forums, and retailer websites) to identify common issues and reliability trends. We specifically look for reported connectivity problems, accuracy of temperature readings, and ease of integration with popular smart home hubs like SmartThings and Vera. While physical product testing isn’t always feasible for every model, we leverage available data and expert opinions within the home automation community to inform our selections, ensuring our recommendations represent the most reliable and feature-rich Z-Wave thermostat options.
FAQs
What is Z-Wave Plus and why is it important for a thermostat?
Z-Wave Plus is an updated version of the Z-Wave protocol offering improved range, battery life, and crucially, enhanced security features like S2 encryption. Choosing a Z-Wave Plus thermostat ensures a more reliable and secure smart home experience.
How do I ensure a Z-Wave thermostat is compatible with my HVAC system?
Before purchasing, identify your HVAC system type (standard gas/electric, heat pump, or electric baseboards). Check the thermostat’s specifications to confirm compatibility. Some thermostats, like the Stelpro KI, are designed for specific systems, while others offer broader compatibility.
Does a Z-Wave thermostat require professional installation?
Not necessarily. Some models, like the 2GIG STZ1-345, are designed as drop-in replacements and are easy to install. However, if you’re uncomfortable working with HVAC wiring, or if your system requires a more complex setup, professional installation is recommended.
What is S2 security and why should I look for it in a Z-Wave thermostat?
S2 security is a stronger encryption protocol for Z-Wave devices. It adds an extra layer of protection against hacking, safeguarding your smart home network. Choosing a Z-Wave Plus thermostat with S2 support is vital for a secure smart home.
Conclusion
Ultimately, selecting the best Z-Wave Plus thermostat hinges on your specific HVAC setup and smart home priorities. By carefully considering compatibility, desired features like scheduling and security, and ease of installation, you can significantly enhance home comfort and energy efficiency.
Investing in a Z-Wave Plus thermostat isn’t just about remote control; it’s about building a more responsive and secure smart home ecosystem. With the right choice, you’ll enjoy greater convenience, potential energy savings, and peace of mind knowing your home is connected and protected.

